ChatGPT told me this:

ChatGPT 3.5

User:
are SMART errors good enough reason for RMA?

ChatGPT:
SMART (Self-Monitoring, Analysis, and Reporting Technology) errors are indicators that a storage device, such as a hard drive or SSD, has detected potential issues with its health or performance. SMART errors can cover a range of issues, including bad sectors, high temperature readings, and other abnormalities.

Whether SMART errors are considered a good enough reason for a Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) depends on the severity and type of errors, as well as the specific policies of the manufacturer or seller. Here are some general considerations:

Severity of Errors: Some SMART errors may be relatively minor and not immediately indicative of a catastrophic failure. Others, particularly those related to critical components like bad sectors, can be more serious. If the errors suggest a high risk of imminent failure, it could be a valid reason for an RMA.

Warranty Status: If your device is still under warranty, the presence of SMART errors is often a reasonable cause for an RMA. Warranty policies vary between manufacturers, so it’s important to check the terms and conditions provided by the company.

Manufacturer’s Policies: Different manufacturers have different policies regarding what constitutes a valid reason for an RMA. Some companies may require a certain threshold of errors or specific criteria to be met before they authorize a return.

Backup and Data Loss: Before seeking an RMA, it’s crucial to back up your data, especially if the SMART errors suggest potential drive failure. Some manufacturers may request proof that you’ve backed up your data before processing an RMA.

Communication with Support: If you’re experiencing SMART errors and are considering an RMA, it’s a good idea to contact the manufacturer’s customer support. They can provide guidance on whether the errors are within acceptable limits or if they warrant a replacement.

Remember that not all SMART errors are equal, and some devices may continue to function adequately despite certain types of errors. However, if you’re concerned about the health of your storage device and it’s under warranty, it’s generally a good idea to reach out to the manufacturer for guidance on whether an RMA is necessary.